Nestled in the heart of the Kentucky Bourbon Trail is a beautifully swanky town voted in Rand Mcnally and USA Today as the “Most Beautiful Small Town in America”. Bardstown, KY is known for its beauty, its bourbon, and its history! Coming straight out of a Hallmark Christmas movie, Bardstown not only has lush history but somewhat of a dark history as well.
There are several places in Bardstown that are claimed to be “haunted” and have a vast amount of paranormal activity. The Talbott Tavern, located right in the heart of Bardstown, has been deemed the most haunted tavern in America. Based on that, this was the choice to investigate.
The Talbott Tavern has a lengthy and interesting history. Dating back from the opening of this tavern in 1779, this place also serves as a bed and breakfast with rooms that Jesse James and Daniel Boone have stayed in. The Talbott has seen several wars, the most impressive that has touched Kentucky is the War of 1812, in which some people call The Second Revolutionary War.
Stories told by employees range from having felt things, seeing things on a regular basis, and hearing strange sounds like barfights when nobody is around and sounds of laughing children running around the tavern. The employees also share tales of soldiers haunting the rooms, as well as bandits from the Old West playing mischievous tricks on guests. Additionally, there are Youtube videos of a strange “Shadowman” that lives and crawls in the hallway and the old ballroom. Unexplained occurrences seem to happen on an everyday basis there.
When talking to Amanda, a waitress at the tavern, she divulged some tales that she had personally experienced. One such tale was significant enough to clearly see her have full body chills as she revealed the story of how she served late at night and witnessed a man come in when they were closing, and no others were around. She saw him in the reflection and noted his long brown coat and blonde hair. In the reflection of the glass she saw him come in to sit but when she turned around there was nobody there. She spoke of another event, where in the concord, which is the old ballroom, she saw a man standing in the corner with dark hollow eyes staring at her until she did a double take and he was gone. Several stories about flying kitchen utensils and people being pushed down the stairs were told by employees.
When speaking to Kristina Brooks, one of the managers of the tavern, she spoke of the history of the old west and Jesse James. The story goes that Jesse had a jailer relative that worked next door at the Old Jailers Inn when it used to be a jail and the hangings of many inmates were public for anyone to come and view. Jesse was a wanted man but that didn’t stop him from frequenting the tavern, and since he had a relative that worked next door, he got away with a lot.
There is a room dedicated to Mr. James called the Jesse James room. In this room is a giant wall mural. It is said that Jesse was so drunk he thought the birds from the mural were flying out at him and he shot up the mural. You can plainly see the bullet holes in the mural that had even survived the fire of 1998.
Kristina also tells the story of paranormal activity that is a constant in the part of the building that was ceiling before the fire. She says there have been guests that claim there is some sort of portal there. This area is now the stairs that lead up to the rooms and the same place where many have felt a shove as if someone or something is pushing them down the stairs.
Are all of these stories real, or are they conjured up the active imaginations of the staff and the guests? Can the video on YouTube be a fake? John Shandor, a Bardstown regular and skeptic does not think the video is faked but that it could be the image of a possum or some wild animal let loose in the upstairs that the light caught just right. He also states that while staff believe what they are saying, they could be imagining certain shadows since a lot of these claims are happening late at night when people tend to get tired. He claims that the weary mind and tired eyes are capable of hallucinations and hearing things that are not there. He believes that people will see what they want to see and with the age of the building any creak or settling sound can sound like an unexplained phenomenon. He is sure that a building that old is certain to have a few critters poking around. When asked what he thinks about the sounds of children’s laughter mysteriously appearing in the hallways (story in video) he answers, “The sounds of children are a joy in this world which carries in sound and could easily have been made by children outside of the building. A building 200 years old is sure to catch the occasional echoes.”
Is there paranormal activity happening in the Talbott Tavern or is it the imagination of staff and guests worldwide? Come see for yourself.